This is a detailed head-to-head comparison between two highly popular, yet distinctly different, automatic watches from the same brand family. The primary difference lies in their design philosophy: the SD1928A is a Pilot/Field watch, while the 40mm model is a classic Dive Watch.

---

VERSUS AI: Head-to-Head Comparison

Feature	SD1928A New Arrival No Logo C3 Green Luminous 39MM Simple Design NH35 Automatic 200M Waterproof Dive Watch Reloj with 10MM Crown	STEELDIVE Men Diver Watch 40mm Automatic Mechanical Wristwatch 20Bar Waterproof C3 Luminous Sapphire NH35
Model Type	Pilot/Field Watch (Flieger/Military)	Classic Dive Watch (Sub-style Homage)
Case Diameter	39mm (Excluding Crown)	40mm (or 41mm depending on specific model)
Case Thickness	12mm	13.5mm - 14mm
Lug-to-Lug (L2L)	49mm	47mm (Approx.)
Bezel	Fixed Stainless Steel (No Bezel)	Unidirectional Rotational Bezel (Often Ceramic)
Crown	10mm Screw-Down, often 'Onion' or Oversized	6.5mm - 7mm Screw-Down, Standard Diver style
Movement	Japan Seiko NH35 Automatic	Japan Seiko NH35 Automatic
Water Resistance	200m / 20ATM / 20BAR	200m / 20ATM / 20BAR
Crystal	Sapphire Crystal with AR Coating	Sapphire Crystal with AR Coating
Lume	Swiss C3/BGW9 Luminous	C3 Luminous (often C3/BGW9 combo)
Aesthetics	Clean, highly legible Arabic numerals, No Logo (as titled)	Sporty, applied indices, with a prominent timing bezel

---

In-Depth Comparison

Design and Aesthetics (The Key Difference)

The fundamental separation between these two watches is their military inspiration:

• SD1928A New Arrival No Logo C3 Green Luminous 39MM Simple Design NH35 Automatic 200M Waterproof Dive Watch Reloj with 10MM Crown: Pilot/Field Watch This model, despite the Dive Watch nomenclature in its full title, is aesthetically a classic German Flieger (Pilot) or Field watch design.

  • Dial: Features a highly legible, minimalist black dial with large, clear Arabic numerals (A-Type Flieger style) or simple markers. The "No Logo" aspect gives it a clean, unbranded look favored by enthusiasts.
  • Bezel: It features a fixed, polished or brushed stainless steel bezel with no timing insert, which defines its non-diver status.
  • Crown: The crown is intentionally oversized (10mm), often in an 'onion' or large diamond shape, a historical nod to WWII-era pilot watches that needed to be operated while wearing gloves.

• STEELDIVE Men Diver Watch 40mm Automatic Mechanical Wristwatch 20Bar Waterproof C3 Luminous Sapphire NH35: Classic Diver This model embodies the archetypal sports watch design, typically a homage to the iconic Submariner or similar popular divers (like the Steeldive SD1953 or SD1954C models).

  • Dial: The dial uses applied geometric indices (circles, rectangles, triangles) with a date window.
  • Bezel: It includes a crucial unidirectional rotating bezel, often with a ceramic insert, for timing dives or other intervals. This is the core functional difference.
  • Crown: It has a standard, medium-sized (around 6.5mm-7mm) screw-down crown protected by crown guards.

Wearability and Dimensions

The subtle difference in case diameter leads to a much larger difference in how the watches wear due to their lug-to-lug length and thickness.

Dimension	SD1928A (Pilot)	40mm Diver (e.g., SF751/SD1954C)	Winner for Compactness
Diameter	39mm	40mm - 41mm	SD1928A (by 1-2mm)
Thickness	12mm	13.5mm - 14mm	SD1928A (Significantly thinner)
Lug-to-Lug	49mm	47mm - 48mm	40mm Diver (Shorter L2L on a slightly wider case)

• SD1928A Proportions: Despite being 39mm in diameter, its 49mm lug-to-lug (L2L) distance is long for its size. This means it will wear large and might overhang smaller wrists. Its primary advantage is its slim 12mm thickness, which allows it to slide easily under a cuff.
• 40mm Diver Proportions: The 40mm Diver, while slightly wider and noticeably thicker (13.5mm-14mm) due to the diving bezel, has a shorter L2L of around 47mm, which often makes it wear more comfortably and securely on a wider range of wrists.

Performance and Build Quality (Similarities)

Both watches offer the same core value proposition common to Steeldive: exceptional specifications for the price.

• Movement: Both use the venerable Japan Seiko NH35 automatic movement (21,600 bph, 41-hour power reserve, hacking, and hand-winding). This is a reliable, easily serviceable workhorse.
• Durability: Both feature 316L Stainless Steel cases, Sapphire Crystal (highly scratch-resistant), and a strong 200m water resistance with screw-down crowns and casebacks, making both truly capable tool watches.
• Lume: Both use bright C3 Luminous material, ensuring excellent low-light visibility, though some reports suggest the specific application on the SD1928 models can be less intense than other Steeldive divers.

---

Pros and Cons

SD1928A New Arrival No Logo C3 Green Luminous 39MM Simple Design NH35 Automatic 200M Waterproof Dive Watch Reloj with 10MM Crown	STEELDIVE Men Diver Watch 40mm Automatic Mechanical Wristwatch 20Bar Waterproof C3 Luminous Sapphire NH35
PROS	PROS
✅ Sleekest Profile: At 12mm thick, it's very easy to wear and fits under shirt cuffs.	✅ Functionality: Includes a functional, unidirectional rotating bezel for timing.
✅ No-Logo/Minimalist Look: The clean dial appeals to those who dislike branding.	✅ Classic Proportions: Shorter Lug-to-Lug (approx. 47mm) makes it wear more compactly than the SD1928A.
✅ Legibility: Pilot watch dials are designed for instant, clear legibility.	✅ Versatile Style: The classic dive watch aesthetic is universally recognized and accepted.
CONS	CONS
❌ Long L2L: The 49mm lug-to-lug might be too long for smaller wrists.	❌ Thicker Case: At 13.5mm-14mm, it feels noticeably chunkier on the wrist.
❌ Limited Functionality: Lack of a timing bezel limits its utility as a pure tool watch.	❌ Less Unique: Dive watch homages are abundant in the market.
❌ Crown Size: The large 10mm crown can sometimes dig into the back of the hand.	❌ Generic Look: More closely resembles countless other dive watches.

---

Who Should Buy What?

Choose the SD1928A New Arrival No Logo C3 Green Luminous 39MM Simple Design NH35 Automatic 200M Waterproof Dive Watch Reloj with 10MM Crown if:

• You prioritize a slimmer profile for a watch that will regularly be worn with sleeves and cuffs.
• You love the classic, ultra-legible Flieger/Field watch aesthetic with large Arabic numerals.
• You prefer a minimalist, 'No-Logo' dial for a clean, unbranded look.
• You have a medium-to-large wrist that can handle the 49mm lug-to-lug length, or if you plan to wear it primarily on a strap.

Choose the STEELDIVE Men Diver Watch 40mm Automatic Mechanical Wristwatch 20Bar Waterproof C3 Luminous Sapphire NH35 if:

• You need or desire the full functionality of a dive watch, including a unidirectional rotating bezel for timing.
• You prefer a classic, universally-loved sporty aesthetic with a familiar look and feel.
• You have a smaller or average wrist and prefer the security of a shorter 47-48mm lug-to-lug distance, even if the case is thicker.
• You want a true "beater" watch that embraces the standard, rugged tool watch form factor.